For years, advertisers relied on precise targeting to deliver results. But changes like Apple’s iOS privacy updates and evolving platform policies have made targeting less accurate. According to Meta, advertisers saw up to a 15% drop in performance following these changes due to limited audience data.
At the same time, platforms are pushing automated solutions like Advantage+ campaigns. These tools give advertisers less control but reward high-quality creatives. In fact, Meta has reported that strong creative can lift campaign performance by as much as 30%, even with broad targeting.
Creative vs. Targeting: How They Work Together
Creative and targeting are partners. Targeting brings the right people, but creative decides if they care. The tricky part is that targeting is weaker now, so creative has to do more of the work. Imagine two campaigns:
-
Campaign A: Super-precise targeting but bland creative. Generic stock photos, uninspired copy. Few people engage.
-
Campaign B: Broad targeting but exciting creative. A story-driven video, real product use cases, and engaging copy. Even people outside the “perfect” audience engage.
The results? Campaign B often wins because platforms reward engagement, lowering ad costs and boosting reach.
Why Creative Has the Edge
-
Algorithms Favor Engagement: Facebook and Instagram lower your CPM when your ads get more likes, comments, or clicks.
-
Privacy Reduces Precision: With less access to user data, targeting has limits.
-
Creative Is 100% in Your Control: While targeting is influenced by algorithms, your creative is fully owned by you.
A Nielsen study found that 56% of ad effectiveness comes from the creative itself, while targeting and reach make up a smaller portion.
How to Build Strong Creative That Works
-
Use Authentic Visuals: Skip stock photos—show real scenarios, customer stories, or brand personality.
-
Experiment With Formats: Test videos, carousels, and short-form reels. Video ads on Facebook and Instagram drive 48% more engagement than static images.
-
Focus on Benefits, Not Features: Write ad copy that highlights what users gain, not just product details.
-
Test Constantly: Run A/B tests to refine which headlines, visuals, or offers resonate best.
Final Thoughts
Targeting still matters, but it no longer guarantees success. In today’s ad environment, strong creative is what captures attention, drives engagement, and makes campaigns profitable. The advertisers who master compelling storytelling and eye-catching design will continue to stand out, even as algorithms and policies change.
