There’s a moment in every advertiser’s journey when they realize the real challenge isn’t just reaching more people — it’s reaching the right people.
Meta’s value-based Lookalike Audiences are designed exactly for that. They allow you to find new customers who don’t just resemble your past buyers — they resemble your best buyers. But many businesses either overlook this tool or use it incorrectly, leaving valuable growth potential on the table.
So how do you actually implement value-based lookalike audiences in a way that drives meaningful impact? Let’s dive in.
What makes value-based lookalikes different?
Most Facebook advertisers are familiar with Lookalike Audiences. You take a seed list (customers, leads, app users) and Meta finds people who are similar in behavior and attributes.
But here’s the catch: regular Lookalikes treat every user equally. Someone who spent $10 on a one-time deal gets the same weight as someone who spends $200 every quarter. That’s a pretty blunt tool for what should be a sharp strategy.
Value-based Lookalikes, on the other hand, allow you to assign a specific monetary value to each user in your source audience. Meta then uses this value to prioritize people who are similar to your highest-value customers.
In other words, you’re not just optimizing for reach — you’re optimizing for quality.
Not sure when to use custom audiences versus lookalikes? This breakdown explores which audience type is best depending on your campaign goals.
What Meta accepts as a value-based source
Before we go further, it’s important to get this right: Meta only allows certain types of sources for value-based lookalike audiences.
Here are the valid options:
-
A Meta pixel with value-tracked purchase events;
-
A mobile app or SDK event source;
-
A product catalogue (with purchase values);
-
A custom audience that includes a lifetime value or recent purchase value column.
That last option — uploading a list with customer values — is often the easiest starting point for small businesses. But it only works if the data is properly structured and includes a “value” field. If that’s missing, Meta won’t treat it as value-based.
If you’re new to Meta’s targeting framework, this foundational guide walks through the essential audience types and how they work together.
How to create a high-quality source audience
The success of your value-based Lookalike hinges on the quality of your original audience. This is not the time to be sloppy.
You want to identify a group of customers who’ve demonstrated real purchasing power or long-term engagement.
For example:
-
Your top 1,000 customers by lifetime value;
-
Users who have made repeat purchases within the last 12 months;
-
High-value clients tracked via your CRM or backend system.
Assign a dollar amount to each customer based on actual value — ideally over a reasonable timeframe like 6 to 12 months. Avoid inflating or fabricating numbers to “trick” the algorithm. Meta normalizes the values anyway, so what matters is the relative value between users.
Once you’ve created this custom audience and uploaded it with the proper value column, Meta can then use it as the seed for your value-based Lookalike.
Pro tip: clean your list before uploading. Remove inactive users or one-time discount chasers who don’t represent the kind of customer you want more of.
Choose lookalike size strategically
When creating your Lookalike Audience, Meta will ask you to choose a size — 1% through 10% of the population in your selected country.
Here’s how to think about it:
-
1% Lookalike: Extremely precise. Ideal for testing with a small budget.
-
2–5% Lookalike: Slightly broader reach with good efficiency.
-
6–10% Lookalike: Wider net for scaling, but less refined.
If you’re testing a new creative, funnel, or product, stick with 1%. Once you find what works, expand to 2% or 3% and monitor performance carefully. Larger sizes demand more spend and can introduce noise if you’re not ready for scale.
Avoid jumping to 10% too early — it’s tempting, but without a strong conversion system in place, you’ll likely burn through budget without clear learnings.
Make sure your creatives match the audience
There’s a silent but powerful link between your audience and your creative. If you’re targeting people modeled after your best customers, your ads should speak to that level of quality and intent.
This is not the place for “flash sale, today only” messages. Instead, highlight product benefits, long-term value, customer satisfaction, or social proof. Use testimonials. Show depth. Build trust.
For example, imagine your top customers tend to buy premium bundles or subscribe to your product monthly. Your creative should reflect that behavior — not a generic “15% off” ad.
You can even use Dynamic Product Ads to show items similar to what high-value customers typically buy. Meta’s algorithms love that kind of continuity.
The goal? Align messaging with expectation. Your audience expects quality — your creative should confirm it.
Keep refreshing and refining
One of the easiest ways to lose performance over time? Letting your seed audience get stale.
Customer behavior changes. Products shift. Seasonality affects value. That’s why it’s essential to refresh your value-based custom audience every 30 to 60 days depending on your industry and product type. Pull fresh data from your CRM or eCommerce platform, reassess who your most valuable customers are, and re-upload.
You can also create multiple value-based Lookalikes. For instance:
-
One based on high average order value;
-
One based on subscription longevity;
-
One based on total referrals or engagement.
Each of these can power a different campaign strategy and help you test what types of value drive the strongest acquisition signals.
Don’t assume one Lookalike will work forever — experiment, analyze, and evolve.
It’s important to note that Meta restricts the use of Lookalike Audiences — including value-based ones — for certain ad categories. If your business deals with employment, housing, or financial products and services, your options may be limited or disabled entirely.
Always check Meta’s Special Ad Category policies before launching.
Final thoughts
Running ads isn’t about brute-forcing your way to visibility. The algorithms are too smart for that to work.
The advertisers who are winning today are using data strategically. They’re identifying their best customers, learning what makes them valuable, and then scaling that insight into growth.
Value-based Lookalike Audiences are a great tool for doing just that. But they only work if you treat them with care.
Choose the right source, assign value honestly, match your creativ, and stay committed to refining your approach over time.
Because the truth is, most businesses don’t need more people in their funnel — they need more people like their best ones.
