Choosing the right campaign strategy is key to success in online advertising. Advantage+ Shopping campaigns often outperform manual campaigns in some areas, but they aren’t always the best choice. This article explains when Advantage+ campaigns work better and when manual campaigns might be the better option.
What Are Advantage+ Shopping Campaigns?
Advantage+ Shopping campaigns are automated ad campaigns on Facebook and Instagram. They use machine learning to automatically optimize things like targeting, bidding, and placements in real-time. This means the system adjusts things for you based on how your ads are performing.
In contrast, manual campaigns require advertisers to make decisions on targeting, bidding, and creative. While you have more control with manual campaigns, it takes more time and effort to manage.
Why Advantage+ Shopping Campaigns Perform Better
1. Faster Optimization
Advantage+ campaigns automatically adjust to improve performance. While manual campaigns require constant monitoring and changes, Advantage+ does this for you. It makes real-time adjustments, improving results more quickly.
Example: If an ad isn’t performing well, Advantage+ will shift focus to better-performing audiences or change the bid without you needing to do anything. For more details on optimizing ad performance, you can read How to Optimize Campaign Performance with Meta Advantage+.
2. Better Audience Targeting
Manual campaigns let you target people based on interests and behaviors. But Advantage+ uses Facebook’s machine learning to automatically find the best audience based on real-time data. This means it targets people who are most likely to buy your products, even without you choosing the audience.
Example: If you sell shoes, Advantage+ can automatically find people who’ve shown interest in running or sports, even if you didn’t specifically target those interests. You can learn more about leveraging audience targeting through Mastering Facebook Lookalike Audiences for Higher ROI.
3. Cost Efficiency
Advantage+ automatically adjusts budgets to make sure they are spent where they will get the best results. With manual campaigns, you have to manage your budget carefully to avoid overspending. Advantage+ reduces wasted ad spend by optimizing your budget for high-performing areas.
Example: If one ad isn’t performing, Advantage+ will reallocate your budget to ads that are driving more conversions.
4. Easier Scaling
Advantage+ campaigns scale better. As your budget increases, the system automatically adjusts targeting, bidding, and placements to ensure the campaign continues to perform well.
Example: If you increase your ad budget, Advantage+ will automatically adjust to make sure the larger spend is used effectively, saving you time.
When Not to Choose Advantage+ Shopping Campaigns
While Advantage+ campaigns have many benefits, they might not always be the right choice for every situation. Here are some scenarios where manual campaigns may work better:
1. When You Need Full Control Over Targeting
If you need very specific targeting, manual campaigns might be the better option. Advantage+ uses automation, but it might not target as precisely as you want.
Example: If you’re targeting a small, niche audience, you may want to manually set the criteria to ensure the right people are seeing your ads. You can read more on custom audience targeting in A Beginner's Guide to Custom Audience Targeting.
2. When Testing New Creatives
If you want to test different ad creatives (like images or copy), manual campaigns give you more control. Advantage+ optimizes ads automatically, but it might not let you test every version as you like.
Example: If you want to test two different ad copies to see which performs best, manual campaigns let you control and monitor the tests closely. For creative testing insights, check out Creative Testing with Limited Budget: What’s Worth Prioritizing?.
3. When You Have Specific Budget Requirements
If you have strict budget constraints or need to control where the money goes, manual campaigns are better. Advantage+ automatically adjusts the budget, but with manual campaigns, you can set exact daily budgets for different audiences or ad placements.
Example: If you want to allocate a certain budget to a specific product or region, manual campaigns give you more control. Learn more on How to Allocate Your Facebook Ads Budget for Maximum ROI.
4. When You Have a Small Catalog or Niche Products
If you have a small number of products or a very specific niche, manual campaigns may be a better fit. Advantage+ is designed to optimize larger product catalogs, and it might not be as effective for smaller or niche businesses.
Example: If you're selling a unique product with very specific target customers, you may want to manually adjust targeting for better results.
Conclusion: When to Choose Advantage+ Shopping Campaigns
Advantage+ Shopping campaigns excel in automated optimization, cost efficiency, and quick scaling. They are perfect for businesses with large catalogs, those looking to scale fast, or those who don’t want to manage everything manually. However, when you need precise control over targeting, creatives, or budget, manual campaigns still have their place.
Key Benefits of Advantage+:
-
Automated optimization of targeting, bidding, and placements.
-
Real-time adjustments for faster performance.
-
Reduced manual effort and time spent on campaign management.
When Manual Campaigns Work Best:
-
Precise targeting and budget control.
-
Testing and experimenting with different creatives.
-
Smaller product catalogs or niche markets.
By knowing when each approach works best, you can make smarter decisions and improve your ad performance on Facebook and Instagram.
